top of page
Search

How to Overcome Tall Poppy Syndrome and Lead With Confidence

Nov 5
7 min read

Key takeaways

  • Tall poppy syndrome is the habit of cutting down people who stand out. Kim Lancer sees it most strongly in Australia and New Zealand.

  • Most capable leaders don't need a new skill or credential before a big moment. They need to reconnect with the capability they already have.

  • Self-doubt doesn't go away. Confident leaders learn to manage it, and that takes discomfort and practice.

  • Self-awareness is where confidence starts, and most of us have less of it than we think.

  • Small, regular reflection beats one-off fixes. Kim's programs run for at least six months for a reason.



Kate De Jong and Sam Morris with headphones on

Kim Lancer grew up in Perth with a message most Australians will recognise: you don't make a fuss about success. Then she spent about 20 years overseas, around six in London and 11 in New York, working in an investment bank and then in leadership development. When she came home about seven years ago, she wanted to show leaders how to overcome tall poppy syndrome and stop playing small.


So she started Tall Poppies Leadership with one aim: to flip the script. Kate sat down with Kim for this episode (Sam couldn't make this one) to talk about why so many capable leaders doubt themselves, and what builds confidence that lasts.


You can't celebrate your wins until you've actually won. — Kim Lancer

That's the rule Kim grew up with. It sounds like humility. In practice it teaches talented people to keep their heads down.


We're Dr Kate De Jong, a PhD engineer turned business strategist, and Sam Morris, a Navy veteran who's spent 20 years in business working out what makes businesses tick and what makes them stall.


What is tall poppy syndrome, and why does it hit Australian business owners so hard?

It's a cultural reflex, and it's stronger here than in most places.

Tall poppy syndrome is the habit of criticising or cutting down people who stand out or succeed. After two decades working in the UK and the US, Kim's view is that it's predominantly an Australian and New Zealand thing.


It's more than a feeling. A 2023 study by Dr Rumeet Billan and Women of Influence+ surveyed 4,710 people across 103 countries and found 86.6% of the working women surveyed had experienced tall poppy syndrome. When the people around you treat ambition as showing off, you learn to downplay your wins, wait for permission and keep your head below the line.


For a business owner, that gets expensive. In our experience it shows up as underpricing, avoiding visibility and waiting until something's perfect before you share it.


Why do capable leaders still doubt themselves?

Because self-doubt is universal, even at the top.

Capable leaders doubt themselves because everyone has an inner critic, and seniority doesn't switch it off. Kim even has a name for hers.


My constant critic, Kevin, my friend. — Kim Lancer

Kim has spent years coaching executives, and she hears the worries they don't say out loud. Her big observation is that when the stakes rise, think a board presentation or a major pitch, most leaders assume they need something new: another qualification, another course, another skill. Usually they don't. They need to reconnect with the capability they already have.


Everybody experiences the same self-doubt. — Kim Lancer

That's a relief to hear, and it changes the goal. You're not trying to get rid of the doubt. You're learning to lead with it in the room. We've talked before about how to get back up when you're knocked down in our post on growth mindset for business owners.


How do you overcome tall poppy syndrome?

Know yourself, trust yourself, be yourself.

You overcome tall poppy syndrome by building confidence on purpose, rather than waiting for it to show up. Kim's framework has three parts: confident leaders know themselves, trust themselves and can be themselves.


  • Know yourself: build self-awareness through regular reflection on your strengths, your values and what motivates you.

  • Trust yourself: manage your self-doubt instead of waiting for it to disappear.

  • Be yourself: lean into your quirks and what Kim calls your superpowers, instead of sanding them down to fit in.


Kim gave the example of a leader preparing for a board meeting with a more intimidating audience than usual. Rather than learning a new skill, they reflected on the landscape, planned how they'd open, cut out the noise and got clear on the impact they wanted to have. That's intentional confidence.


It also takes discomfort. Kim was clear on that.


You have to be uncomfortable to get there. — Kim Lancer

Kate agreed. We ran workshops for female founders for years, and the message never changed: get used to feeling uncomfortable, because it doesn't stop when you grow.


You can't escape that feeling of being uncomfortable constantly. — Dr Kate De Jong

Is confidence different for women in business?

Women tend to name it. Men tend to hide it.

In Kim's experience the self-doubt is the same, but women are more willing to say it out loud, while men often take longer to admit it because of what's expected of them.


Kate spent 15 years as an engineer working mostly with men, then years coaching women in business, and she sees confidence as a bigger barrier for women. Kim pointed to research showing women hold off applying for roles until they meet far more of the criteria than men do. A commonly cited figure, discussed by Tara Sophia Mohr in Harvard Business Review (2014), is that men apply for jobs when they meet about 60% of the qualifications, while women apply only when they meet 100%.


Belonging matters too. Kim described walking into a business lunch of about 400 people, around 80% of them men, and instantly feeling she didn't belong, despite years working in investment banking. If a seasoned executive coach feels that, it's worth going easy on yourself when you feel it too.


Where does self-awareness fit in?

It's the first step, and most of us are worse at it than we think.

Self-awareness is the foundation of confidence, because you can't trust yourself or be yourself until you know yourself. The catch is that most of us overestimate how self-aware we are.


I love the research by Tasha Eurich when she found that 95% of all people think they're self-aware. — Dr Kate De Jong

Organisational psychologist Tasha Eurich puts the real number closer to 10 to 15%, research she covers in her book Insight (2017) and in Harvard Business Review (2018). Kim draws on Daniel Goleman's model from Emotional Intelligence (1995), which has four domains: self-awareness, self-management, social awareness and relationship management. Her point is that it has to start with self.


Kim's tools are simple questions. She asks clients to rate their energy from 1 to 10. She asks when they're most productive, which three people they spend the most time with, and whether those people give or drain their energy. One senior leader realised four of his five key relationships had been volatile lately. No wonder he felt flat, and seeing it took some of the sting out of his self-criticism.


A key part of emotional intelligence is to be actually kinder to yourself. — Kim Lancer

That means noticing your wins, including the small ones, because your brain won't do it for you. If you want to go deeper, read our posts on becoming more self-aware as a leader and developing emotional intelligence as a leader.


How does this play out in a team?

Confident teams talk about what just happened.

In a team, low confidence and low trust show up as passive conflict and avoided feedback. Kim's fix is to name what's happening in the room.


She starts every team engagement with assessments and pre-interviews, because she never assumes a team is already high performing. In one recent session, an emotional moment got swept aside. Kim stopped and asked the group what had just happened. Someone eventually named the discomfort underneath, and that was the breakthrough.


She's also firm about who she works with. Her firm won't take on a leader who's been sent to be fixed, because people forced into development spend their energy resisting it. The choice, and the work, belong to the leader.


Kim practises this herself. Early in her career she pushed hard for a change at the bank, got her way, then got feedback that she was too pushy. That led her to a 360 review and a coach of her own. These days she gives herself a lot more grace.


Frequently Asked Questions

What is tall poppy syndrome?

Tall poppy syndrome is the tendency to criticise or cut down people who stand out or succeed. It's strongly associated with Australia and New Zealand. It can lead capable people to downplay their achievements and hold back.


Can you overcome tall poppy syndrome as a business owner?

Yes. Start by noticing when you downplay your wins, then practise naming them. Building self-awareness and managing self-doubt, rather than waiting for it to disappear, makes it easier to stand tall.


Does self-doubt ever go away?

Not completely, and Kim Lancer says that's normal because everyone experiences it. The aim is to recognise it, name it and lead anyway.


How long does it take to build leadership confidence?

Longer than a single workshop. Kim's programs run for at least six months, because confidence grows through reflection, practice and discomfort over time.


What can you do this week?

Three small steps to stand a little taller.

  1. Write down three wins from the last month, including small ones, and tell one of them to someone you trust.

  2. Rate your energy from 1 to 10 each day this week, and note which people and tasks moved the number up or down.

  3. Give your inner critic a name. Next time it pipes up before a big moment, notice it, then plan how you'll open and what impact you want to have.


Confidence like this builds slowly. As Kim put it:


It's never the one moment, it's the 10 years of work. — Kim Lancer

Standing Tall: Flipping the Script on the Tall Poppy Syndrome with Kim Lancer cover art


Further Reading



Ready to Work Through the Whole Thriving Business Wheel?

The Thriving Business Launchpad takes you through every quadrant of the Thriving Business Wheel with AI prompts you can work through in your own time, at your own pace. Earn. Keep. Grow. Lead.


Join the list and you'll be first to know when it's live.


 
 
 

Comments


bottom of page