top of page
Search

Why Isn't My Marketing Working? 7 Signs Your Business Doesn't Know Who It Is Yet

3 days ago
6 min read
  • If you're asking why isn't my marketing working, the problem often sits underneath the marketing, in a business identity that isn't clear yet.

  • Generic messaging, a logo-first brand and an elevator pitch that rambles are all signs of the same gap.

  • Being specific about who you help feels risky, but it's what lets the right people recognise themselves.

  • Getting clear on why you do what you do is the place to start, and it's rarely as quick as people expect.



Kate De Jong and Sam Morris with headphones on

You know the networking event. Everyone stands up for their introduction, and someone talks for three minutes.


“Someone stands up and waffles for three minutes and you still don't know what they do at the end of their elevator pitch.” — Dr Kate De Jong

We've all been that person at some point. And if you're sitting there asking why isn't my marketing working, there's a good chance it's not the posts, the ads or the platform. It's what sits underneath them.


Kate and Sam both see business owners who've been going for years and still can't say clearly who they are and who they help.


“Businesses that have been in the game for sometimes two, three, four plus years and still not super clear on their business identity.” — Dr Kate De Jong

Here are seven signs that's you.


What are the signs your marketing has an identity problem?


They usually show up long before you'd call it a branding issue.


The clearest sign is that people can't tell what you do or why they'd pick you. The rest tend to follow from that.


Checklist graphic: seven signs your marketing is missing its foundation

1. Your elevator pitch takes three minutes


If you need three minutes to explain what you do, you probably haven't worked out the one sentence that matters yet. Long explanations usually mean the thinking isn't finished.


2. You keep your options wide so you can help more people


This is the one almost everyone says to us at the start.


“Every business owner we know comes to us and says, oh, but I want to keep my options open and wide so that I can help more people. But it actually works in reverse.” — Dr Kate De Jong

The more specific you are, the easier it is for the right person to read your website and think, that's me.


3. You did the logo before you knew what you stood for


It's the most natural thing in the world. You have a business idea, so you get a logo and some website copy. Kate's point is that the order's back to front: identity first, then messaging, then the visual brand.


“Most brands we know launch straight into a visual branding.” — Dr Kate De Jong

4. Your copy sounds like everyone else's


AI can write you a lot of words very quickly. But if you don't know who you are, it can only give you the average of everyone else.


“You'll end up with generic messaging, which is just vanilla and blah.” — Dr Kate De Jong

5. Competitor research leaves you flat


You look at the businesses doing what you do, and they seem miles ahead.


“You're at chapter one and they're at chapter 20 or 50 or 100, and it can take the wind out of your sails.” — Dr Kate De Jong

Sam reads the same research the other way.


“If other people are doing it, that means there is definitely a market for it.” — Sam Morris

When you're clear on who you are, competitor research shows you the gap you can fill. When you're not, it just shows you everyone who got there first.


6. You can't say why you do what you do


You can describe the service. You can't say what you believe, or why it matters to you. Sam's blunt about where that leaves your marketing.


“You've got to understand your why and you build from there.” — Sam Morris

7. You don't know what people say when you leave the room


We used to ask workshop groups a simple question: what is a brand? Kate's answer has stuck with us.


“It's everything other people say you are when you're not in the room.” — Dr Kate De Jong

If you couldn't guess what people say about your business after you've gone, your identity isn't landing yet.


Why does a clear identity make marketing work?


Because people decide with their gut long before they read the details.


A clear business identity makes marketing work because it gives people a reason to choose you, not just a description of what you sell. Simon Sinek built a whole philosophy on this in Start with Why (2009): people connect with what you believe before they care about what you do.


Kate mentioned a classic psychology study on the episode. In 1978, Ellen Langer and her colleagues asked people queuing at a photocopier whether they could go first. Giving a reason, even a fairly empty one starting with “because”, made people noticeably more likely to agree. Later studies have questioned how far that effect goes, so we wouldn't build a strategy on one word. But it does show how much people respond to a reason.


Your why is that reason. Without it, your marketing has to work much harder. We wrote about the how-to side in How to Define Your Business Identity (Before You Spend Another Dollar on Marketing).


Where do you start if you saw yourself in this list?


With one question most people find harder than they expect.


If a few of these signs hit home, start with your why. That's exactly why we made our free prompt, Why Should Anyone Pick You? It walks you through the thinking with AI, in your own time, and you finish with words you can actually use.


Sam's done this work more than once, and she still recommends it to people who think they've already nailed their why. Kate went through it again recently and came out with a breakthrough she wasn't expecting. It's free, and it's the first step of everything else we do.


Frequently Asked Questions


Why isn't my marketing working even though I'm posting regularly?


Often the issue sits underneath the posting. If your business identity isn't clear, your content can be consistent and still not tell people why they should choose you.


What is business identity?


It's the foundation of your brand: why you do what you do, where you're going, how you'll get there and the values that guide you, plus who you help and the problem you solve.


Do I need to niche to make my marketing work?


Being specific makes it easier for the right people to recognise themselves. It feels like you're shutting people out, but in our experience it works in reverse.


Can AI write my marketing if my identity isn't clear?


It can write plenty of words, but they'll tend to be generic. AI does far better when you can tell it clearly who you are and who you help.


Dr Kate De Jong is a PhD engineer turned business strategist. Sam Morris is a Navy veteran who's spent 20 years in business working out what makes businesses tick and what makes them stall.


Three questions to sit with this week


  1. Could you explain what you do and who you do it for in one sentence your best client would recognise?

  2. If your business walked into a bar, what kind of bar would it be, and how would it behave?

  3. What do you hope people say about your business when you're not in the room, and what do you think they actually say?


“What you're selling is last on the list here.” — Sam Morris

Ep #2 | Define Your Business Identity: The Foundation of Revenue Generation cover art


Further Reading




Ready to Work Through the Whole Thriving Business Wheel?


If this list stung a little, you're in good company, and you don't have to sort it all out alone. Start with our free prompt, Why Should Anyone Pick You?, and get clear on the reason people should choose you.


Then come with us through the rest. The Thriving Business Launchpad takes you through every quadrant of the Thriving Business Wheel with AI prompts you can work through in your own time, at your own pace. Earn. Keep. Grow. Lead.


Join the list and you'll be the first to know when it's live.


 
 
 

Comments


bottom of page