top of page
Search

The Feedback That Made Kate Cry: How Others See You as a Leader

4 days ago
5 min read
  • How others see you as a leader can be very different from how you see yourself, and most of us can't see the gap on our own.

  • Kate's first 360-degree review showed her a pattern her team could see and she couldn't.

  • Sam has had the same shock from the other direction: people saw her as more closed, and more together, than she felt.

  • Curiosity, vulnerability and being comfortable with not knowing are the qualities we lean on to keep closing the gap.



Kate De Jong and Sam Morris with headphones on

About twenty years ago, Kate was leading a team of eight in an engineering company. She thought she was doing a good job.


“Here I was thinking that, you know, I'm a really good leader, I'm so approachable, I'm friendly, I'm knowledgeable.” — Dr Kate De Jong

Then the company put her through her first 360-degree assessment. Her team, her peers and her managers all rated her. She got two pictures back side by side: how she saw herself, and how they saw her.


“I just felt my eyes sting. All of a sudden I was crying, and like, oh my gosh, how did I not know?” — Dr Kate De Jong

We talk a lot on the podcast about how others see you as a leader, because it's one of the most useful things you can know and one of the hardest to find out. This is the story behind why it matters so much to both of us.


What did Kate's feedback actually show?


A leader who thought she was assertive, and a team who saw something else.


Kate's feedback showed plenty of positive, people-focused behaviour, and almost none of the assertive behaviour a leader needs. What her team saw instead was a lot of approval-seeking: trying to be liked, struggling to say no, and steering around conflict.


“I thought I was strong, assertive.” — Dr Kate De Jong

That's the part that stung. She wasn't a bad leader. She was blind to a pattern everyone around her could see. That moment started a journey she says she's still on, and it's a big part of why she does the work she does now.


Is the gap between how you see yourself and how others see you normal?


Very. The research suggests most of us have one.


Yes, and it's far more common than most of us want to believe. Organisational psychologist Tasha Eurich and her team studied self-awareness with nearly 5,000 people. In her 2018 Harvard Business Review article she reported that about 95% of people believe they're self-aware, and estimated only 10 to 15% actually meet the criteria.


Diagram of the self-awareness gap between how you see yourself and how others experience you

Eurich splits self-awareness into two parts. Internal self-awareness is how clearly you see your own values, feelings and strengths. External self-awareness is how well you understand how other people experience you. Kate had done plenty of inner work. What she was missing was the outside view.


Has Sam had the same moment?


Yes, from a direction she didn't expect.


Sam's always seen herself as an open book. Probably too open, she'd say. So it rocked her when a friend told her she was hard to get to know.


“Isn't that interesting that my perception was one thing, and then she's telling me we don't really know who you are?” — Sam Morris

She's had the opposite shock too. People would tell her she had it all together at times when she felt like she was barely keeping up. Same person, two very different pictures, and neither one was the one she carried around in her own head.


We find that comforting, honestly. If two people who spend their working lives helping business owners see themselves clearly still get surprised, it says something about how normal the gap is.


What helps us keep closing the gap?


Three qualities we come back to again and again.


For both of us it comes down to three things: curiosity, vulnerability and being comfortable with not knowing. Kate's view is that if you keep practising those, your self-awareness keeps growing.


Curiosity is the one Sam lives in. Plenty of people find it uncomfortable to admit they don't know something. Sam's the opposite.


“When you hear I don't know, I get really excited because that's just giving me something else now that I'm gonna go and learn about.” — Sam Morris

Vulnerability is harder. You have to ask for feedback and then sit with what comes back, even when it stings like Kate's did. And being comfortable with uncertainty means you stop needing to be the person with all the answers.


This matters beyond your own growth. If you lead a team, the culture you create follows what you actually do, not what's on the wall. Sam put it well.


“It is the unspoken rules that you follow that are actually more damaging than the spoken rules.” — Sam Morris

Amy Edmondson's research on psychological safety, published in 1999, found teams learn more when people feel safe to take interpersonal risks, like admitting a mistake or asking a question. A leader who can't see their own patterns is likely to make that harder without meaning to. We went deeper on the practical side in How to Become More Self-Aware as a Leader and How to Develop Emotional Intelligence as a Leader.


Frequently Asked Questions


How do I find out how others see me as a leader?


The most direct way is to ask for feedback, and a structured 360-degree assessment makes it easier for people to be honest. Kate's first one showed her a pattern she'd never have spotted on her own.


What is the difference between internal and external self-awareness?


Tasha Eurich describes internal self-awareness as how clearly you see your own values, feelings and strengths. External self-awareness is how well you understand how other people experience you. You need both.


Is it true that only 10 to 15% of people are self-aware?


That figure is Tasha Eurich's estimate from her research with nearly 5,000 people, reported in Harvard Business Review in 2018. She found around 95% of people believe they're self-aware.


Why does a leader's self-awareness matter for a small team?


Your team takes its cues from how you actually behave. If you can't see your own patterns, it's harder to build a team where people feel safe to speak up.


Dr Kate De Jong is a PhD engineer turned business strategist. Sam Morris is a Navy veteran who's spent 20 years in business working out what makes businesses tick and what makes them stall.


Three questions to sit with this week


  1. If your team described you in three words, what do you think they'd say, and how sure are you?

  2. When did someone last tell you something about yourself that surprised you, and what did you do with it?

  3. What's one thing you'd find hard to say “I don't know” about?


“If you just practice curiosity, vulnerability, and comfort with uncertainty. That is the path.” — Dr Kate De Jong

Ep #15 | 95% Of Us Think We Are Self Aware - WRONG! cover art


Further Reading




Ready to Work Through the Whole Thriving Business Wheel?


The Thriving Business Launchpad takes you through every quadrant of the Thriving Business Wheel with AI prompts you can work through in your own time, at your own pace. Earn. Keep. Grow. Lead.


Join the list and you'll be the first to know when it's live.



 
 
 

Comments


bottom of page