How to Create an Irresistible Offer Your Clients Actually Want to Buy
Key takeaways
An irresistible offer solves a specific, urgent problem for a specific person. Vague offers for everyone get ignored.
Sell the result, not the process. Clients want to know where they'll end up, not how many sessions they'll sit through.
Validate before you build. If people pay for the offer, then you build it, and you shape it with your first clients.
Price on the value of the outcome, not your hours, and reach for risk reversal and social proof before you reach for a discount.
Three tiers beat one option or ten. Most buyers pick the middle, and real scarcity works where fake countdown timers don't.
Kate once launched a program for women who had a business idea but weren't ready to launch. It sold quickly. Then the real work started. She and her team had to build each week's content while paying clients waited for it, and partway through they changed direction because the people in the room needed something different.
“We actually pivoted our approach along the way to give them what they needed.” — Dr Kate De Jong
That's the messy, honest version of how to create an irresistible offer. You don't get it right on paper first. You get it close enough to sell, then you let real buyers show you what it needs to be. In this episode of the Thriving Business Podcast, we unpacked what makes an offer hard to say no to, and the traps that make good businesses look forgettable.
We're Dr Kate De Jong, a PhD engineer turned business strategist, and Sam Morris, a Navy veteran who's spent 20 years in business working out what makes businesses tick and what makes them stall. This was the second part of the revenue quadrant of our Thriving Business Wheel, and we called the offer the engine of revenue generation.
How do you create an irresistible offer?
It's specific, it solves something urgent, and it promises a result people want.
An irresistible offer solves a real, pressing problem for a clearly defined person, and it's framed around the outcome they get. If any of those three are fuzzy, people scroll past.
“It has to solve a very specific problem for a very specific person.” — Sam Morris
Kate added the urgency test. If the problem is a 'one day I should sort that out' problem, people put it off. If it's keeping them up at night, they act. Sam's example was a done-for-you money service aimed at Gen X business owners who feel stretched in every direction. The service itself is a dashboard, an action plan and an optional monthly check-in. But that's not what she leads with.
“The transformation is going from being panicked about money to having a plan.” — Sam Morris
That line does the selling. The dashboard is just how it gets done.
Why should you sell the result instead of the process?
Because nobody buys hours of your time. They buy where they'll be afterwards.
Clients care about the result you can get them, not the steps you'll take. Lead with the change, then explain the process as proof you can deliver it.
“What people actually want to know is what's the result you can get me.” — Dr Kate De Jong
This lines up with Clayton Christensen's jobs-to-be-done idea. In 'Know Your Customers' Jobs to Be Done' (Harvard Business Review, 2016), Christensen and his co-authors argue that people 'hire' a product to make progress on a job in their lives. Your offer is the thing they hire. Describe the job it does.
Sam added a twist that catches a lot of experts out. You might know exactly what a client needs. That doesn't mean they want it in that shape. If your method relies on weekly sessions and your audience hates weekly sessions, the offer won't sell, however good the method is.
“But people don't buy needs, people buy wants.” — Sam Morris
How do you validate an offer before you build it?
Ask people to pay. Interest is cheap; a payment is data.
Validate an offer by selling it before it's fully built, then building it with your first buyers. Market research tells you how big the market is. Market validation tells you whether anyone will actually hand over money.
“Market validation is about ensuring that the market will actually buy what you have to sell.” — Sam Morris
Sam's suggestion for people starting out is a beta round. Offer the service at a reduced price in exchange for a testimonial, a review or honest feedback. You'll find beta clients in business groups and online forums. Kate's caution was that a newer provider can over-promise, so be clear about what the beta includes.
This is the same logic Eric Ries set out in The Lean Startup (2011): put a minimum viable product in front of real customers early and learn from what they do, not what they say. Kate's version is simpler.
“And if people buy, then you start building it.” — Dr Kate De Jong
If you're working out what kind of business model your offer sits inside, our post on how to design a business model that gives you revenue and freedom covers that next layer.
How do you build trust when people don't know you yet?
Show proof, and borrow credibility until you've earned your own.
Build trust by making your social proof visible and by naming who you've learned from. People look to what others have done before they commit, especially when they're unsure.
Kate described a business owner who had more than 150 Google reviews sitting on her profile and none of them anywhere a buyer would see them. The proof existed. It just wasn't doing any work. Robert Cialdini called this social proof in Influence: The Psychology of Persuasion (1984): when we're uncertain, we look to the actions of people like us to decide what to do.
If you're new and don't have reviews yet, we talked about borrowed credibility. Name the mentors, methods and programs you've trained in. It tells a buyer your approach has a track record, even if your business doesn't yet.
Should you discount your offer to get more sales?
Usually not. A price cut is the reflex, and it rarely fixes the real problem.
Discounting is usually the wrong first move. If an offer isn't selling, check the problem, the promise, the proof and the risk before you touch the price.
“The first thing out of the gate is slash the price.” — Sam Morris
Sam meant that as a warning, not advice. Kate's view was that pricing should follow the value of the outcome to the client.
“So pricing needs to reflect the value of the thing you are delivering for the person, not the time.” — Dr Kate De Jong
We went deeper on this in our episode on pricing for profit. If you're still charging by the hour, that's the one to listen to next.
What is risk reversal, and should you offer a guarantee?
It moves the risk of a bad decision off the buyer and onto you.
Risk reversal means you carry more of the risk so the buyer doesn't have to, usually through a guarantee. It works because buyers are wary, but it only works with clear terms.
“This is because the market is really sceptical. They don't trust anyone.” — Dr Kate De Jong
Kate's example was coaches who promise a return on investment, such as a two-for-one return on what the client spends. Sam's point was that responsibility has shifted. As she put it, it's “shifted off the customer and onto the service provider.” But a guarantee needs conditions. The client has to show up, do the work and keep records. Without that, it's a gimmick that's hard to claim and hard to honour.
How many options should your offer have?
Three. Not one, and definitely not ten.
Give people three options. One option turns the decision into yes or no, and too many options make people freeze. With three, most buyers settle on the middle.
“So give people three options. They typically end up going for the middle one.” — Dr Kate De Jong
Kate's example was a coaching offer with a basic tier of one session a month, a middle tier with two sessions a month plus group coaching and resources, and a VIP tier of weekly one-to-one coaching for around $20,000 up front. Sam's tip was to add value through things that don't cost more of your time, like templates, guides or community access.
The research backs the middle-option effect. Itamar Simonson and Amos Tversky's 1992 paper 'Choice in Context: Tradeoff Contrast and Extremeness Aversion' in the Journal of Marketing Research found that an option becomes more attractive when it sits in the middle of a set and less attractive at the extremes. Your middle tier should be the one you most want people to buy.
Do scarcity and urgency still work in marketing?
Real limits do. Fake ones cost you trust.
Scarcity and urgency still work when they're real: a capped number of places, a genuine start date, a cohort that closes. Fake countdown timers do the opposite.
“It's 2026. No one trusts the timer anymore.” — Sam Morris
Kate's retreat example was a real cap of 15 people. That's honest scarcity. Cialdini lists scarcity as one of his principles of influence, but the principle depends on the limit being true. Once buyers spot a timer that resets every time they refresh the page, every other claim you make looks shaky too.
Frequently Asked Questions
How do you create an irresistible offer for a small business?
Start with one specific person and one urgent problem they have. Describe the result they'll get, back it with visible proof, reduce their risk, and give them three clear options. Then test it by asking people to pay before you build the whole thing.
What's the difference between market research and market validation?
Market research looks at how big a market is and who else is in it. Market validation tests whether people will actually buy what you're offering, ideally by asking them to pay. You can do plenty of research and still have an offer nobody buys.
Should I offer a money-back guarantee?
A guarantee can lower the barrier for sceptical buyers, but it needs clear terms. Spell out what the client must do, such as attending sessions and completing the work, so the guarantee is fair to both sides.
Why do three pricing tiers work better than one?
One option makes the decision a yes or no, and too many options create confusion. Three tiers give people a comparison, and research on extremeness aversion shows buyers tend to favour the middle option.
What can you do this week?
Three questions to test your own offer.
Write one sentence that names the specific person you help and the urgent problem you solve. If it could describe half your competitors, narrow it.
Rewrite your offer's headline around the result, not the process. Cut session counts and deliverables from the first line.
Find your hidden proof. Where are your reviews and testimonials sitting right now, and could a buyer see them before they enquire?
“And if people buy, then you start building it.” — Dr Kate De Jong
Further Reading
Clayton M. Christensen, Taddy Hall, Karen Dillon and David S. Duncan, Know Your Customers' Jobs to Be Done, Harvard Business Review (2016)
Eric Ries, The Lean Startup (Crown Business, 2011)
Robert B. Cialdini, Influence: The Psychology of Persuasion (1984), and the principles of persuasion summary from Influence at Work
Itamar Simonson and Amos Tversky, Choice in Context: Tradeoff Contrast and Extremeness Aversion, Journal of Marketing Research 29(3), 281–295 (1992)
Related post: How to Choose a Business Model as a Coach (Without Copying Someone Else's Playbook)
Ready to Work Through the Whole Thriving Business Wheel?
The Thriving Business Launchpad takes you through every quadrant of the Thriving Business Wheel with AI prompts you can work through in your own time, at your own pace. Earn. Keep. Grow. Lead. Join the list and you'll be the first to know when it's live.
Comments